Mistral Large 4 reviewed the first draft of SPEC-011 Sharing a Store-Truth Folder against the code on 2026-11-18. It ran read-only through the
vibeCLI (--agent ask) in the main checkout, and was asked for defects only. It reported 12 findings. Claude checked each against the code: 11 are right, and 1 is partly right. All are folded into the draft. No code exists yet, so none of this could be checked by a test. Each finding was checked by reading the code it cites.Sources: the answer and the brief, kept outside the repository in
/home/daniel/.cache/agent-usage/vibe/2026-11-18-0042-spec011/(ANSWER.md,brief.md; cost $0, Mistral Large 4). code:crates/sophia-hash/src/merkle.rs,crates/sophia-store/src/types.rs,logic.rs,folder.rs,sqlite.rs,crates/sophia-interface/src/edit.rs.
| # | finding | right? | what was done |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Record files are named by component, but a member’s id is member_digest(component, index). The envelope wrote no id and no index, so foreign records could not be placed. | right (merkle.rs member_digest) | The envelope writes id; the index is the record n number; the import checks id = member_digest(component, index) for every record (§3.1, §5 step 2). |
| 2 | A log entry import is no LogOp. Every decoder would fail on it. | right (types.rs LogOp, LogOp::parse in the decoders) | A new LogOp::Import, stated as a format change (§5 step 5). |
| 3 | A fact’s relation inputs carry a log position. After an import, the round trip changes bytes and is_stale misreports. | partly | The bytes do not change, because a fact is written as stored and its id covers the version. But such a fact reads as stale after an import. That is now stated as a loss of the rebuild (§3.2, §6). |
| 4 | ROOT in the tree is never verified, and it conflicts in every merge. | right | The root digest is computed, never stored in the tree (§3.3). |
| 5 | fact-external/ was called derivable. It is not: only it records that a fact predates every file. | right (folder.rs, fact_external_key and its use in replace_in) | Exported as the set facts-external (§2, §3). |
| 6 | Annotation and fact ids were not recomputed on import. | right | Recomputed with Annotation::new and Fact::new; a mismatch is refused (§5 step 2). |
| 7 | Fact and annotation inputs were not checked for existence. | right | Added to §5 step 3. |
| 8 | A union merge of lineages can give one id two predecessors, or a cycle, with no conflict. | right (put_lineage keys on (lineage, id)) | The import refuses both (§4, §5 step 4); added to acceptance 3. |
| 9 | Scanning for <<<<<<< refuses a source file that contains that text. | right | Markers are detected only where a line is expected, never inside an envelope’s length-delimited block (§5 step 1); acceptance 3 tests a source that contains them. |
| 10 | A namespace may contain / (inside backquotes), and _root can collide with a real namespace. | right (validate_path) | File names are percent-encoded, with upper case encoded too, which also makes them safe on case-insensitive file systems. The root file is @root (§3). |
| 11 | The check “every member that comes from files has a manifest” cannot be decided, and “no name claimed by two manifests” would refuse shared generic functions. | right (edit.rs adds members in store-truth stores; replace_files allows shared generic functions) | Only the direction manifest → live member is checked, and only definition names must have one owner (§5 step 4). |
| 12 | store/truth-since was set to a digest, where SPEC-010 §3 defines it as a log position. | right (folder.rs take_truth) | It is set to the import entry’s seq (§5 step 5). |
Not reported, as Mistral checked: owner/, member/, defined-in/, fact/ and nominal-index/ can be computed from manifests and nominal entities, and removed_seq is invisible to every read path (removed_seq IS NULL).