Where the work stands, for the next session to start from: the branch, what was done last, what is next with the facts it needs, and what is open. A session that ends updates it; a session that starts reads it after
AGENTS.md. History belongs in git and the notes it points to, not here: replace what is stale rather than appending.
Sources: original to this repository; Feature Backlog, Refactor 2026-11,
AGENTS.md
Last updated: 2026-11-16, after P4’s AD half (the coupled replay through a HardConstraintFactor under ForwardDiff and Zygote), committed on dev-danielb and pushed (through 11d4e255). P4 is done. The backlog got section G the same day (notes only).
Branches and worktrees
| checkout | branch | state |
|---|---|---|
~/Code/CategoryTheory/Lenticulum.jl | dev-danielb | P4 AD committed (LenticulumCore extended_gaussian.jl and its extensions, Mycelium gaussian.jl, Lenticulum hard_constraint.jl, constraint.jl; tests extended_gaussian_ad.jl, hard_gradient.jl). Not pushed |
~/Code/CategoryTheory/Lenticulum.jl-mistral | mistral/review | at 60903bc4 with the P4 AD diff applied (without the LP-043 fix); Mistral’s probes in scratch/p4ad/. Stashes, all droppable: mistral-wt-p25-applied-stale-2026-11-16 and older. LenticulumCore’s test environment there is instantiated (--project=lib/LenticulumCore.jl/test runs its probes) |
Pushing: a plain git push origin dev-danielb works from every shell (~/.ssh/config maps
github.com to the mathstruct key). If GitHub itself rejects the key, push over HTTPS with gh’s
credentials (git -c credential.helper= -c credential.helper='!gh auth git-credential' push https://github.com/MathStruct/Lenticulum.jl.git dev-danielb).
Done last
- P4, AD half (committed):
ExtendedGaussian{T<:Real}; decompositions on the values, the derivative carried by (one formula for ForwardDiff and Zygote); a first-order rank change refused under ForwardDiff; non-mutating_independent_join; the hard factor’s free energy through . Details in Backlog Done 2026-11 (2026-11-16) and extended_gaussian “Derivatives (P4, 2026-11-16)“. - Verified: LenticulumCore, Mycelium, MyceliumLearning, Lenticulum suites after the review fix;
AlgebraicFactors, AdversarialFactors, ImplicitLayers, VariationalDiffusion before it (the fix touches only
the empty-eigenvalue case of
_psd_split). Logs in~/.cache/lenticulum/p4ad/. - Review: LP-043 Findings of the review of P4 (Mistral; Zygote threw on a belief with no Gaussian direction; fixed, regression test).
Next
P4 unblocked P2 (hard inputs in the free energies of SwitchingConstraintFactor, the plate paths
and the frozen beliefs of the gradient; with DiagonalCoupling the fixed-belief gradient refuses a
graph whose variables have hard directions, “no canonical form”) and P6 (HardConstraintFactor in
plates and in MeanField() nodes). Neither is designed yet; pick one with the maintainer.
Open
- P4 limits: Zygote has no rank check (a rank-changing tangent gives the constant-rank
derivative silently); second derivatives (nested duals) through extended Gaussians are refused;
_moving_flat_split(P25) stays ForwardDiff-only. P27: mixture × extended product. - P25/P26 limits: a parameter that changes a rank only at second order (a backward message’s
as leaves a rank-deficient value; leaving 0 in a cluster) gets the
constant-rank derivative while the value is discontinuous there; Zygote does not go through the
flat path’s moving directions; the plate methods (
factor_messageswith a shared metric) and an inference with a dual upstream of a flat path are untested under moving flat directions;cluster_marginalof a flat class under ForwardDiff is untested. - P24’s Zygote rule gives the incoming messages no tangent (
@not_implemented); differentiating through inference with cluster nodes stays closed (their messages are built by mutation). - Backlog section G (decisions, control and games, G1–G10; 2026-11-16, from Daniel’s question on reinforcement learning and open games): rows only, from a reading of code and notes. Nothing is designed or run; G5–G8 need P16. Priorities are proposals.
- AlgebraicFactors, ImplicitLayers and AdversarialFactors run in CI only weekly: a change to the core should run their suites locally too (that is how the AlgebraicFactors break was found).
- Mistral review agent, refused commands: on P13 its six refusals all began with
cd … &&, and itsjuliacommands without output redirection ran; on P21 the refusedjuliacommand had> … 2>&1(which ran on P23). Next brief: give the command without redirection and say “never prefixcd”. - Mistral review agent:
vibe ... --agent review --trust --workdir ../Lenticulum.jl-mistral(~/.claude/CLAUDE.md). A review needed about 140 turns; give it 100 and continue the session withvibe -cif it stops. On I6 it kept probing through three continuations (about 175 turns, one session) and wrote no answer. Briefs now ask for an answer file appended after every probe and a stop by turn 70 (~/.claude/CLAUDE.md, “Reviews that never answer”);--model glm-5-3(priced, new sessions only) was tried on I6: it wrote its answer probe by probe as asked, five probes, no defect, then also stopped at 100 turns ($2.35) before its summary. On I19 (Mistral Large, $0) it wrote four probes but no answer file at all, and three of the probes had errors of their own (a misparsed tolerance, a parenthesis, a keyword read for a NamedTuple): run and repair its probes before believing a failure. On I20 it kept the answer file but was stopped by--max-price 1after 71 turns:cost_usdcounts list prices even for the free Mistral Large (3.9 M input tokens, $1.01), so give a free-model review--max-price 3to reach its turn limit. On P20 (2026-11-16) both runs lost every command to acd … &&prefix (not on the allowlist). On P23 the brief gave the exact command line to copy (julia -t auto --project=<env> scratch/p23/probe1.jl > ….out 2>&1) and it ran six probes; on P24 the command line without redirection and “never prefixcd”: every probe ran and it finished with an answer file ($0.41). Keep doing that. On P25 the commands ran but it spent its 100 turns on 26 debug variants and wrote one entry: run its last probes yourself. On P4 (AD) no answer file at all; its last probe (needing imports added) found the one defect. Its probes need the package’s test environment (--project=lib/<Pkg>/test); say so in the brief. A watcherwhile pgrep -f "vibe -p …"matches its own command line and never ends: matchvibe-rswithpgrep -xor wait on the PID.