open-problem

Status: resolved (2026-11-12). One defect found and fixed, a ForwardDiff crossing the first version of P1 left open. Also: one test that did not build what its comment said, one header that overclaimed (a pre-existing limit, now @test_broken) and stale note text. One finding is not a defect. Related: Feature Backlog (P1, P21), LP-027 Findings of the review of the I18 plans.

Sources: a review of the uncommitted P1 change by Mistral (vibe --agent review), run with Julia in the helper worktree Lenticulum.jl-mistral (2026-11-12). Its answer is in ../Lenticulum.jl-Review-2026-11-12/P1-from-mistral-2.md (the first run stopped at its turn limit), its scratch scripts are under scratch/p1/ in that worktree (probe_req1.jl, probe_req2.jl, probe_stack.jl, probe_nonlinear.jl, probe_jlarrays.jl). code: lib/Mycelium.jl/src/gaussian.jl (combine, belief_distance, can_damp, _damp for an ExtendedGaussian and a GaussianBelief), lib/Lenticulum.jl/src/gaussian.jl (_likelihood_message); tests: lib/Mycelium.jl/test/forms_crossing.jl, lib/Lenticulum.jl/test/forms_crossing.jl; notes: lib/Lenticulum.jl/src/gaussian.md “Where the two forms meet”, lib/Mycelium.jl/src/gaussian.md “Extended Gaussians”.

Problem. P1 asked for tests where the two forms of a flat likelihood meet (a flagged GaussianBelief, the form under ForwardDiff, and an ExtendedGaussian, the form on values). The change reviewed fixed two defects those tests found (_likelihood_message built the extended form of a dual η; damp was a silent no-op on a mixed pair). The brief gave Mistral the requirement, not the reasoning.

#findingright?what was donetest
F1A variable that hears a plain extended message (a rank-deficient factor with plain parameters) and a dual flagged one (the factor being differentiated) throws in infer! under ForwardDiff: combine and belief_distance converted the GaussianBelief side with extended, which has no method for dualsright. Reproduced by Mistral (probe_req1.jl, R1b) and by the extended test: against the code before the fix the two-factor inference errs in all 10 instances with MethodError: no method matching svd!(::Matrix{ForwardDiff.Dual...})a mixed pair whose GaussianBelief holds non-float numbers is taken in canonical form when the extended side has no hard directions (_canonical); with hard ones combine and belief_distance throw an ArgumentError and can_damp is false. Plain-value pairs are unchangedLenticulum test/forms_crossing.jl, “ForwardDiff through an inference with flat backward messages” (two factors on x, derivative against the dense joint); Mycelium test/forms_crossing.jl, “a mixed pair with dual numbers goes through the canonical form” (60 random pairs, 1 080 checks)
F2The Mycelium test said “a mixed pair with dual numbers” but built Real arraysrightreplaced by the testset of F1 with ForwardDiff dualsas F1
F3The Lenticulum test’s header claimed every parameter dual for all three factors; NonlinearFactor with a dual expansion point throws earlier, in _jacobian (Float64(::Dual))right; the limit predates P1header corrected; the limit recorded as @test_broken and in P21Lenticulum test/forms_crossing.jl, “known limit, NonlinearFactor’s backward message at a dual expansion point”
F4gaussian.md still said the crossings are untested and that _likelihood_message checks “the element type”; the backlog listed P1 as proposedright for the worktree’s copy, which did not have the note changes; “the element type” was still stale in the main checkoutcorrected—
F5With JLArrays, the new mixed damp returns a host ExtendedGaussian, where before P1 it returned the device message undampedright as a description, not a defect: ExtendedGaussian is a host type (Vector, Matrix), and combine of the same pair already returned it on the host before P1nothing changed—

Leaning / resolution. F1 was a real defect of the same kind as the one P1 fixed in _likelihood_message: a place that decided by representation and forgot that under ForwardDiff only some arrays carry duals. F2–F4 corrected tests and notes.

Not checked: the distance near the rank threshold on a run (lib/Mycelium.jl/src/gaussian.md); a mixed pair where Λ, not only η, holds duals is covered by the same _extendable test but was not run separately.