open-problem

Status: resolved (2026-11-12). One defect found and fixed with a test; one suspicion not reproduced. Related: Feature Backlog (I5), LP-024 Findings of the review of 2026-11-09.

Sources: a review of the uncommitted I5 change (the parameter and state trees read by position) by Mistral, run with Julia in the helper worktree Lenticulum.jl-mistral (2026-11-12). It stopped twice at its turn limit before writing a final list, so the findings below come from its scratch scripts there (scratch/i5_review.jl, scratch/i5_ad.jl, scratch/i5_plate_scaling.jl), which the maintainer’s session ran again. code: lib/Mycelium.jl/src/passing.jl, lib/MyceliumLearning.jl/src/gradient.jl; note: lib/Mycelium.jl/src/passing.md, “The trees by position”.

Problem. Mistral checked the I5 change against its requirement: every schedule returns a NamedTuple, and the very tree it was given when there is no state; missing keys are appended in the order of their first write; the tied rule (the last write wins); plates with block rows and a stateful factor; residual probes do not write; step! on a NamedTuple; Zygote and ForwardDiff through the free energy against the reference; parameter_step and free_energy_gradient against finite differences. Rerun by the maintainer’s session: 195 checks pass in i5_review.jl and 26 in i5_ad.jl. The one error in i5_review.jl is a defect of the scratch test itself (MaybeCount has no parameterlength), which i5_ad.jl corrects.

#findingright?what was donetest
1parameter_step with an optimiser state given as a Dict throws MethodError: no method matching _stored(::Dict…); the old code read it with haskey and getindex, so a Dict workedright, reproduced (i5_ad.jl). The docstring asks for a NamedTuple, but the old code accepted a Dict and nothing announced a change_stored(d::AbstractDict, name) = get(d, name, nothing)MyceliumLearning test/gradient_couplings.jl, “parameter_step: an optimiser state given as a Dict”: one step with a Dict equals one with the NamedTuple; it fails without the method
2_row_items scans all energy rows for each key in _envelope_gradient: O(keys × rows)not reproduced: Mistral’s i5_plate_scaling.jl found the cost linear at the sizes it tried. The rows are few (one per plate and channel set), so it would matter only for graphs with many platesnothing changed—

Leaning / resolution. Fixed with a test where reproduced; the second is recorded only.