open-problem

Status: resolved (2026-10-26). Complete capped enumeration, predicate-based structural checks and joint inversion on unobserved blocks. Related: LP-008 No conformance test for the factor interface, L-SPEC-001 The Factor Interface, factor.

Sources: original repository analysis; code: lib/LenticulumCore.jl/src/channels.jl, lib/VariationalDiffusion.jl/src/factor.jl, lib/VariationalDiffusion.jl/src/implicit_factor.jl, lib/VariationalDiffusion.jl/test/conformance.jl

Theory (CT-ML wiki): Bayesian Inversion

Problem. The predicate accepted every assignment with an unobserved channel but the list omitted latent and multiple-target splits. Inversion returned only the first unobserved block. Three broken membership tests and one broken dimension test recorded it.

Resolution. Option A: supported_polarities now returns all default-precision Observed/Unobserved/Latent assignments through arity four (65 entries). One-target/all-other- observed entries retain their order at the front; the remainder follows lazy traversal. Above four channels it throws ArgumentError pointing to supports_polarity and polarities. The predicate remains the authority. The lazy iterator is type-unstable, since each assignment has its own type, and complete traversal still costs exponential work.

Core hasnopolarity and isunidirectional retain list-based defaults; diffusion overrides both without enumeration. Mycelium’s issink delegates to hasnopolarity. Graph polarity resolution constructs each per-target assignment from available messages and checks it with the predicate; it does not need a list.

invert and likelihood_message return a joint belief on concatenated unobserved blocks in channel order. Point messages select the prox solution; Gaussian and mixture messages restrict the existing full-state approximation. Likelihood messages divide out the product of diagonal target anchors. An improper Gaussian is allowed; an improper mixture component throws because its normalized weight is undefined. The diffusion prior remains in the message. factor_message(f, target, …) remains per-target. Joint prior points use the same concatenation; shared-block points retain their prior convention.

Checks. The four broken assertions now pass in “Diffusion factor partial conformance”, with no LP-017 polarity_gap or message_gap. For the isotropic fixture the field integrates to : the site has precision , so multiplying by gives . Both target coordinates and the covariance are checked. “Diffusion polarity enumeration and cap (LP-017)” checks counts at arities two, three and four, equality with lazy traversal, ordering and structural answers above the cap. “Joint diffusion messages (LP-017)” checks noncontiguous unequal blocks, joint-prior cotangents, point/Gaussian/mixture messages, anchor pooling and correlated covariance. “Joint mixture rejects undefined anchor division (LP-017)” checks that removing the only confining anchor throws instead of assigning normalized weights to flat components. “Joint mixture anchor pooling (LP-017)” checks recovery of both components and weights when a two-target mixture site is multiplied by its diagonal anchor. Core “Lazy polarity enumeration (LP-017)” checks lazy traversal independently of a list. Game gaps remain in LP-009; this does not claim arbitrary-prior or stochastic-backend conformance.

Validation run (2026-10-26)

Full suites, using julia --project=lib/<Package>.jl -e 'using Pkg; Pkg.test()' (and --project=. for Lenticulum):

PackagePassFailErrorBroken
LenticulumCore230000
Mycelium459000
Lenticulum775000
VariationalDiffusion1143000
ImplicitLayers316000
AdversarialFactors232003
AlgebraicFactors14396000

VariationalDiffusion’s original testset passed 889 assertions in 6m50.1s; its conformance file passed 254, including the joint and cap testsets above. The remaining three broken assertions belong to Ratio particle conformance (LP-016).