Status: closed (2026-10-25). Related: L-SPEC-001 The Factor Interface, L-ADR-0006 Separate likelihood_message from invert, LP-003 SquaredNorm does not check its metric, LP-008 No conformance test for the factor interface, LP-009 Game-level free energy is declared but not implemented.
Problem. A read-only review of master by Codex (2026-10-25, of the 16 commits after 5a850764: the issue #8 energy work, the cherry-picked review-argon fixes, L-ADR-0006) found defects that the test suites passed over, each with a reproduction. Besides reopening LP-003, LP-008 and LP-009:
entropyreturned a bare number for the fiveLenticulumfactors, though its contract makes it an element of the energy space; applying the factor’s ownGradedScalarisationto it threw aMethodError.- The nonlinear factor’s
likelihood_messageandinvertdisagreed foriterations > 1: onlyinvertrelinearised at the posterior, so the BP message was not the site of the posterior (against L-ADR-0006). For , noise 0.1, prior , , four iterations: posterior mean 1.9938 frominvert, 2.4634 from the prior times the message. - Predictive
LikelihoodFactorfree energy setfitand the conditional entropy both to 0, because they cancel in the plain sum; any other scalarisation got the wrong value (ordinal, thresholds , : both are 0.8448). - The mixture
likelihood_message(VariationalDiffusion) kept the posterior’s weights after dividing out the anchor; the weights also need each component’s log-partition change (two modes, anchor : weights 0.68/0.32 against 0.59/0.41). - The prior’s cotangent in
implicit_factor_pullbackwas the first unobserved block’s cotangent even when an incoming point overrode the prior: 0.20 where finite differences give 0. - RQ-002 and Universal Approximation for Implicit Diffusion Learners §3 claimed an error from uniform continuity alone; uncentred shifts give .
Resolution. Codex implemented the fixes test-first on codex/review-fixes, one commit each; Claude reviewed them, kept predictive mode working for the count likelihoods (Codex had made it throw) by summing their conditional entropy as a series, and corrected the notes: 1 → 4a49ca5c; 2 → c03014c3, with the graph message on the same routine in bb3af9e9; 3 → c5f07b5a, 3be38b3e; 4 → 4c184538; 5 → 84b69146; 6 → the notes now say , for , and only for centred shifts and . The review is Lenticulum.jl-Review/10_Review_of_master_(Codex).md (outside the repository).
Lesson. Records were marked closed on the strength of commit messages. A resolution names the code or test that closes it, and is checked against the code before the status changes.